What you'll be able to do after this guide: write a 1 to 5 fit score that an agent can apply consistently, and use it to decide which prospects get expensive research and outreach.
ICP stands for ideal customer profile: a description of the customers you're best placed to win and serve. A fit score measures how closely a prospect matches it.
Why a score, and why 1 to 5
An agent researching 15 companies a day needs a consistent way to say "this one is worth a person's time and this one isn't". A five-point scale is coarse enough to apply consistently and fine enough to rank. Stored as a rating field, it can be sorted and filtered, which the outreach agents rely on to pick who goes first.
The shape of a good rubric
Every rubric we use builds the score from three things:
- Strength of the signal. How sure are we that the company has the problem we solve? This uses the evidence tiers in Grade Your Evidence.
- Commercial fit. Is the company the right size and type to buy?
- Reachability. Have we found the actual decision-maker, with a confirmed way to contact them?
The score never measures whether outreach has happened. That is what status fields are for.
Worked example: Fernhill's Segment A rubric
| Score | Meaning | Fernhill's Segment A version |
|---|---|---|
| 5 Strong | Confirmed signal, clearly qualifies, decision-maker with a confirmed email | Competitor product confirmed from the company's own pages, Direct type, named decision-maker with a confirmed work email |
| 4 Good | One step short on evidence or on contact | As 5, but the product is a strong inference rather than confirmed, or there is no confirmed email |
| 3 Plausible | A real fit, weaker on both | Plausible product, Self-serve type, in the size range, decision-maker found |
| 2 Weak | Circumstantial evidence only, or unclear who decides | Only sector assumptions; or no confident decision-maker |
| 1 Poor | Shouldn't be on the list | Wrong buyer, excluded category, or the company is not legally active |
Rules that make scores trustworthy
Reserve 5 for cases where you can point at the thing you would replace. Some companies show a clear need (for example, a regulation they must comply with) but no evidence of a current tool or a current problem. Cap these at 4. A confirmed obligation tells you a need exists; it doesn't tell you there's a pain you can name in a message.