What you'll be able to do after this guide: teach an agent to label every finding by how sure it is, so it never presents a guess as a fact in a CRM record or a message to a prospect.
Why evidence grading matters
Prospecting agents are confident writers. Without a rule, "this company probably uses Competitor B" becomes "I see you use Competitor B" in a message, and a prospect who doesn't use it stops reading. Grading every finding protects your credibility and makes research checkable.
The three tiers
| Tier | Meaning | Examples | How it can be used |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1: Confirmed | Stated by the company itself or a primary source | Their own job advert naming the product; a branded login page linked from their site; a vendor case study naming them; a named accreditation on their site | Safe to cite in a message |
| Tier 2: Strong inference | Good evidence, not first-hand | An enrichment tool's technology tag; technical fingerprints in their website's code (tell-tale file names that reveal which product built a page); a matching reviewer on a review site | Corroborate before stating as fact; otherwise ask as a question |
| Tier 3: Circumstantial | Plausible, not evidenced | "Companies in this sector usually..."; a generic job title | Never cited, and never enough on its own to add a record |
Ask the agent to tag every signal in its notes with its tier, for example "Competitor B login page at a branded subdomain (an address like learn.brightside.example) linked from their footer (Tier 1)".
Worked example: the same company, three ways
A Fernhill agent researching Brightside Ltd finds:
- An enrichment tool lists Competitor B in their technology. Tier 2.
- Their careers page has an advert for a "Competitor B administrator". Tier 1.
- They're in a sector where Competitor B is popular. Tier 3.
Finding 2 can go in a message. Finding 1 supports it. Finding 3 is noise and stays out of the record.
Rules for evidence that misleads
These came from real mistakes, and each is now a standing rule.
Look at the real page before concluding "nothing there". An agent once dismissed several strong prospects because search results and the companies' own marketing suggested a polished setup. Opening the actual pages showed sites assembled from several add-ons and an old website system repurposed as a login portal: exactly the problem Fernhill solves. Negative conclusions need more evidence than positive ones.